Our society is getting primed to “stand in line.” Standing in line is a big deal for me. I avoid it at all costs. My kids suffer b/c we rarely do any amusement parks or other kid “line standing” activities. They’ll survive.
One place it really bugs me is the second line at the warehouse store to get out the door. This is standard procedure at Costco and Sam’s, and I’ve see it at Walmart too. I understand standing in line to check out on a busy day at peak shopping time. Today was an example. Sunday afternoon is not the day to visit Costco – no evidence of a recession this afternoon at the warehouse. I, along with the herd, maneuvered our way through the store to buy imported products and then stand in long lines to pay our dollars. Then we stand in another line so they can check to see if you’ve stolen anything. At this point I’m thinking “false imprisonment.” In law school, this subject fascinated me.
Here’s a definition of false imprisonment: Intentionally restraining another person without having the legal right to do so. It’s not necessary that physical force be used; threats or a show of apparent authority are sufficient. False imprisonment is a misdemeanor and a tort (a civil wrong). If the perpetrator confines the victim for a substantial period of time (or moves him a significant distance) in order to commit a felony, the false imprisonment may become a kidnapping.
Since they are not letting me leave their establishment until I succumb to their request, I think this line falls under the tort of false imprisonment. You have the threat of security tackling you if you skirt the line and leave without the red line on your receipt. As I stood in line to get out the door today, this was going through my brain. I thought about cutting and making run for it, but I had two kids and there was too much traffic blocking my way. I eyed the customer service entrance and could have made my way out through its entrance. I really thought about it. I’m sure they’d have called security. Didn’t want my kids to see me get arrested.
What legal right do they have to retain me after I’ve paid for my goods? After I have paid for my merchandise, it belongs to me. However, the second line is probably somewhere in my membership agreement, so chances are I’ve given up my right to leave without being searched. One day we’ll have to open our purses to show “no stolen goods” before we leave and I”m sure we’ll all get in that line too.

So why do they do this? And WHY DO WE COMPLY IS THE BIGGER QUESTION?????? I understand a store may stop me if they have probable cause to believe I have stolen. Instead of putting the burden on the store to establish probable cause, they stop everyone. It is easier for them to make us all wait for one hired person with a magic marker than for them to bear the burden of stopping those have truly given cause. And they don’t want to risk stopping someone who has not given prob cause and being sued. So it is like the airport… we all take our shoes off.
We’re all becoming drones. They tell us to stand in line and we do it. The lines get longer and we still stand in line. Gov’t heathcare will be great. Almost as fun at getting a new driver’s license.
I double dog dare you to leave Costco or Sams without your red line. Let me know how it goes. Tape it, put it on Youtube and you’ll be famous. We’ll start a revolution. Yes, I was the kid at school who thought up ideas and others got in trouble.
On a side note, it you really want to get rich – think of something remarkable to do while standing in line and get a copyright.
Posted by Kris
Posted by Kris
Posted by Kris